How to run structured interviews without an ATS, and what the tools cost

You don’t need an applicant tracking system (ATS) to run structured interviews. Ask every candidate the same questions, write down what a strong answer looks like, collect each interviewer’s feedback before anyone compares notes, and record the decision. Google Docs, Forms and Sheets do that for free. Paid tools charge per role or per interviewer, and some record the call.

Prices checked on each company’s pricing page on . Hirezen wrote this page and makes one of the tools below; we say where it fits and where it doesn’t.

Eight ways to run structured interviews, with prices

Monthly billing, in US dollars. “Records the call” means it keeps audio or a transcript.

OptionInterview questionsRecords the callCandidate trackingPricePriced by
Google Docs, Forms and SheetsYou write them in a docNo. Gemini notes in Meet do, on paid WorkspaceA sheet you keep by hand$0 on a free Google account. Note-taking in Meet needs Workspace Business Standard, $16.80 a userFree, or per user
NotionYou write them in a pageOnly with AI Meeting Notes, on BusinessA database you keep by handFree $0. Plus $12 a seat. Business, with AI Meeting Notes, $24 a seatSeat
The note-taker in Zoom or MeetNone; it summarizes what was saidYesNoZoom Basic is free: AI notes three times a month, meetings up to 40 minutes. Zoom Pro $16.99 a user. Meet: Workspace Business Standard, $16.80 a userUser
Dovera free ATSYou write them in its interview plans; AI suggests questionsAI notetaker on PremiumYes, it’s an ATSFree ATS $0, unlimited users and jobs. Premium $199 a monthFlat
YardstickYou build the interview plan in the ATS, with AI helpNoYes, it’s an ATSFirst 3 jobs free, for the life of the account. Then Core $49 a month + $29 per open role, or Scale $149 a month + $19 per open roleOpen role, plus a base fee
MetaviewNotetakerNone; it writes notes from the callYes, records and transcribesNo; connects to your ATSFree: 25 calls a month per user. Pro $60 a user, unlimited callsUser
Interview SignalA live guide with follow-ups, in a desktop appYes, live transcriptionNoFree: 20 minutes in total. Solo $49 a month, one person. Team $59 a seat, three-seat minimumSeat
HirezenA plan for each interview: start from one of 209 free plans, or write your ownNoCandidates you add, with stages and recorded decisions; no job posts or applicationsFree for one open role and up to 10 teammates. Team $69 a month for three open roles, then $25 a role. To start Team, email us; there’s no self-serve checkout yetOpen role

What three open roles and five interviewers cost

Monthly, if all five need a paid account. These tools do different jobs: some track candidates, some structure the interview, some take notes.

  • Docs, Forms and Sheets: $0
  • Dover Free: $0. Premium, with the notetaker: $199
  • Yardstick: $0 for the account’s first three jobs, then $136 ($49 + 3 × $29)
  • Notion Plus: $60 (5 × $12). Business, with AI Meeting Notes: $120
  • Hirezen Team: $69. One open role at a time is free
  • Meet note-taking (Workspace Business Standard): $84 (5 × $16.80)
  • Zoom Pro: $84.95 (5 × $16.99)
  • Interview Signal Team: $295 (5 × $59)
  • Metaview Pro: $300 (5 × $60). The free plan’s 25 calls a month per user may be enough

Per-seat prices go up with each interviewer who needs an account. Per-role prices go up with each role you open, and Yardstick adds a base fee. A founder who joins every final interview is a sixth seat, and still three roles.

The free setup: Docs, Forms and Sheets

For one role, this is all most small teams need. Make one folder per role and share it with the people interviewing.

  1. A plan for each interview, in a doc.

    List the questions in order, how long each takes, and under each question what a strong answer shows. We call those signals. For “What was still running three months after you left, who owned it, and how do you know?” one signal is “Knows because they checked - a message, a metric, a visit - and says when.” To skip the blank page, start from a plan in our library.

    Browse interview plans

  2. A feedback form for each interview, in Forms.

    Ask for the candidate, the interviewer, Yes, Not sure or No for each signal, a sentence of evidence, and one recommendation: Strong No, No, Yes or Strong Yes. Leave “View results summary” off. Google shows that summary to everyone who can fill in the form, so the second interviewer would see the first one’s answers before writing their own. Add interviewers as responders, not editors: Google gives a form’s editors its responses spreadsheet. Point every form at one responses spreadsheet that only the person running the debrief can open, and keep it out of the shared folder.

  3. A tracker, in its own spreadsheet in the shared folder.

    One row per candidate: the stage, the next step and who owns it, and the decision with its reason.

  4. A debrief once every interviewer has submitted.

    Filter the responses to one candidate and read them before anyone talks, so nobody anchors on the first opinion. Talk through where interviewers disagree, then record who decided and why.

Where it falls short

  • More roles mean more copies. Each role gets its own docs and forms, and they drift apart.
  • Nothing keeps interviewers on the plan. If one skips or rewrites questions, the answers stop being comparable.
  • Nothing checks coverage. A must-have skill that no interview asks about turns up in the debrief, too late.
  • You chase feedback yourself. The form doesn’t remind anyone, so the debrief waits or starts without it.
  • Each interview has its own form. Seeing one candidate across every interview means pulling rows together by hand.

Which to choose

  • One role, two or three interviewers

    The free setup. Hirezen’s free plan covers the same role with the plan, the ratings and the debrief in one place.

  • You want job posts, applications and a pipeline anyway

    An ATS. Dover’s is free. Yardstick builds the interview plan into the ATS and charges per open role after your first three jobs.

  • You want notes or a transcript of each interview

    A note-taker: Zoom’s or Meet’s if you already pay for it, Metaview for notes on every call, or Interview Signal for a live guide plus transcription. Tell candidates first, and get consent where the law requires it. You still judge the answers.

  • You won’t record interviews

    Docs, Forms and Sheets, Dover’s free plan, Yardstick, or Hirezen.

  • Nobody on the team has written an interview plan

    Start from a written one: Hirezen’s library of 209 plans, or the AI question suggestions in Dover and Yardstick.

Where Hirezen fits, and where it doesn’t

Hirezen is for the interviews themselves: the plan, the feedback and the debrief. Each interview has a plan with a timed opening, the questions with their signals, and a close. For each role you list the skills you’re hiring for and mark the must-haves. Each interview covers up to two skills, and by Hirezen’s own rule a must-have shows as not covered until two interviews ask about it.

During the interview, the interviewer marks each signal Yes, Not sure or No. AI drafts the feedback from those ratings and their notes; the interviewer edits it and makes the recommendation. Interviewers on the same interview can’t see each other’s feedback until they submit their own. The debrief shows every interviewer’s ratings and recommendation side by side, without averaging them, and records the decision and its reason.

It isn’t an ATS. You add candidates yourself, and there are no job posts, application forms or calendar sync. When you book an interview you enter the time, the interviewers and the call link, and Hirezen gives you a calendar invite to send. If you move to an ATS later, you can copy feedback out in Greenhouse scorecard format or as plain text. No bot joins the call and nothing is recorded.

Questions

Do I need an ATS to run structured interviews?
No. The US Office of Personnel Management’s guide sets three rules for a structured interview: every candidate gets the same questions in the same order, every answer is rated on the same scale, and interviewers agree beforehand on what a good answer is. None of that needs an ATS. An ATS adds job posts, applications and a candidate pipeline.
What’s the cheapest way to run structured interviews?
Google Docs, Forms and Sheets on a free Google account, at $0. Dover’s free ATS and Yardstick’s first three jobs also cost nothing, and Hirezen is free for one open role at a time.
Do all interviewers need a paid account?
It depends on the tool. On per-seat tools (Notion, Zoom, Metaview, Interview Signal) each person who uses it needs a seat. Dover’s free ATS has unlimited users. Yardstick’s interviewers open their prep kit from a magic link, with no seat to buy. In Hirezen everyone signs in, and seats are free: up to 10 people on the free plan, no limit on Team.
Can I run structured interviews without recording them?
Yes. The structure comes from the plan and from rating each answer as you hear it. The interviewer writes the evidence down; nothing else has to be stored.
How do I keep interview feedback private?
Collect it so no interviewer sees another’s before submitting their own. In Google Forms, leave “View results summary” off, add interviewers as responders rather than editors, and keep the responses spreadsheet out of the shared folder, open only to whoever runs the debrief.
When does a small team need an ATS?
When applications arrive faster than you can log them, when you need job posts and a careers page, or when several people book interviews and the invites collide.
What are signals in an interview?
What a strong answer shows, written under a question before the interview. The interviewer marks each one Yes, Not sure or No as they hear it, so the feedback rests on what the candidate said. The interview rubric shows examples for six skills. See the interview rubric